I've just finished reading another book by Lindsey Pennington. The previous books by this author I had read were exceptionally good; very literary, would have been my verdict. Since I'm so picky about careful language, and grammar, I guess that those aspects of the writing must have been really good.
This latest story, though, started out very promisingly, but sort of became a little scattered as it went along; actually the entropy in the writing got very bad indeed. But I had made a connection with the characters, so I just had to finish the story.
There are two women, the older one of whose marriage has broken up, but who is a very determined, very giving, very lovely person; and the younger a psychologist and counselor, patient and understanding, but just discovering that she is getting multiple sclerosis—still only minor symptoms, but eventually going to be serious.
They love each other very much. But the older woman is diagnosed with cancer, which eventually kills her, and the younger, the caretaker, is left devastated, with the only child of the deceased woman, a boy, to look after. She is eventually persuaded to seek companionship in a lesbian bar.
Also at the bar, with her crazy friends and her sister, is a young lawyer. She's straight, but these girls are her friends, so she tags along with them, always to this same bar. For a bet, she's asked to kiss a girl, a one-time exercise. Of course, she ends up kissing our other protagonist. It's a good kiss; neither of them can stop thinking about it. The young lawyer runs home from the bar.
The story revolves around the lawyer's clumsy attempts to deal with her unexpected new attraction to a woman, after a decade or more of being only interested in men. She finds out the home address of the psychologist, Kerry, and bursts into her home, uninvited.
There are some interesting circumstances; the lawyer—an attractive girl—is half Scottish, half Korean; and her mother is a typical, interfering Korean mother. There are four children, all girls, all different, and all real characters.
The biggest character of them all is the lawyer herself, who was extremely picky about the men she wants to date; she has a checklist, and she scores them all on a 100-point scale. (She's even got a scale for women, to help her lesbian friends out.)
It's sort of fun, though nothing really unexpected happens. The comic attitudes of the young women, and their zany conversation kept me hooked, though I thought the long-suffering psychologist was just a little too patient with her rude lawyer client.
But there are just so many mechanical errors that I strongly suspect that there was a very capable editor for the previous stories, but not for this one.
Kay
